On Saturday, November 9th, 2013, Kinkaid's middle school debate team attended what is likely to be the largest junior high debate tournament in Houston this year, hosted in Klein ISD with 14 programs participating.
Kinkaid had 30 seventh graders competing for the very first time and 10 eighth graders competing for the first time this school year.
The eighth graders participated in Lincoln-Douglas (LD) Debate, in which students compete against an opponent one-on-one. All students debated three preliminary rounds and then the top 16 based on record advanced to the octofinals. Kinkaid had seven students in the top 16, which is a big accomplishment, especially given the high level of competition this year. Four Kinkaid students went on to quarterfinals, and then, by the time the tournament advanced to semifinals, Kinkaid was the last school standing, having eliminated all other schools.
This is called a "closeout" in debate, and Kinkaid’s top four students were declared co-champions. They took home the trophies for first, second, third, and fourth place. The Kinkaid students who were part of the semifinals closeout were Sam Segal, David Liang, Taqi Hasnain, and Lauren Ho. Also advancing to the top 16 were Anish Odhav, Jiya Ghei, and Minhhy Truong. In addition to determining wins or losses in the debate rounds, judges also award students points for their public speaking skills. Kinkaid received recognition for having three of the top 10 speakers with Sam Segal winning first place, Jiya Ghei winning second place, and Minhhy Truong winning ninth place. Finally, Thomas Garrison had a winning record but missed advancing based on the tiebreaker. The LD students were debating a complex topic about whether or not attorney-client privilege hinders the truth-seeking efforts of our legal system.
The seventh graders participated in Public Forum (PF) Debate, in which the students compete in two-person partnerships. These students debated the harms and benefits of domestic surveillance by the National Security Agency. When the top 16 were announced for this event, Kinkaid had one quarter of those advancing. This was especially impressive given that the seventh graders faced opponents all day with more competitive experience than them. Kinkaid’s top finisher was the partnership of Ellie Lucke and Callie Rosenthal who advanced to the quarterfinals or top eight. Also reaching the top 16 were the partnerships of Reeves Cameron/Jack Neblett, CG Marinelli/Onuchi Ndee, and Brian Schroeder/Andrew Yang. Finally, Graham Parsons received the second place speaking award out of 84 students.
On top of the individual awards earned by the Kinkaid students, the team received the First Place Sweepstakes Award for small schools. The tournament divided the 14 participating schools into the seven schools with under 100 entries and the seven schools with over 100 entries in three categories: speech, debate, and theater. Even though the team was only entered in the debate category, 40 Kinkaid students competed well enough overall to take home the top prize. The whole middle school debate team should be proud of this award whether or not they advanced since all preliminary round wins counted toward this accomplishment.
Congratulations to all of these Middle School debate students. They worked very hard for the past month preparing for this event.
-- Middle School Debate Coach, Stacy Thomas